I have the pleasure of owning both polishes and I let my pictures speak for themselves :) This is two coats of each polish.
|Essie on pointer and ring. H&M on middle and pinkie.|
As you can see Wintersky is much more pale and silvery whereas For the Twill of It is much more dark grey. Yes, the both have a duo chrome effect to lilac and green but they are not dupes! They both have a much deserved place in any collection! :)
Speaking of grey/lilac/green duo chromes released this fall, For the Twill of It is much more similar to OPI Peace & Love & Opi! I don't have the OPI one but here's a bottle comparison.
From what I have seen on other blogs they are VERY similar but not dupes either. Apparently there is a tiny difference in the shade of the lilac and in the amount of visible brush strokes. This is not my own conclusion but only what I've read.
I think the H&M is the best alternative here. I like that it's so pale and that it is the most unique one of these three. It also has by far the best price!
Which one is your favorite?